Last Updated: November 5, 2026
Quick Summary
To measure campaign performance, start by tying the campaign to one business outcome, then track KPIs that match its objective and channel. Set up consistent tracking before launch, calculate ROI, ROAS, cost per lead and cost per acquisition, and use a holdout test to confirm the campaign caused the results.
- Write the business outcome in one sentence before choosing any metrics.
- Track one leading indicator and one lagging indicator for every campaign.
- Set one UTM naming standard and enforce it across every location.
- Judge campaigns on attribution and incremental lift against a holdout group.
- Use the same ROI, ROAS, CPL and CPA definitions for every location to compare fairly.
Table of Contents
- Start With Business Outcomes and Campaign Objectives
- Choose the KPIs That Match Each Campaign Objective
- Set Up Tracking Before the Campaign Launches
- Calculate ROI, ROAS, Cost Per Lead and Cost Per Acquisition
- Separate Attributed Results From Incremental Impact
- Build a Campaign Performance Report Template
- Book Your Local Visibility Score to Start Measuring Your Locations
- Frequently Asked Questions
Marketing teams across a franchise network often ask the same question: is this campaign actually working? For a Canadian franchise system with 50 or more locations, the answer depends on whether you measure results against business outcomes, not just clicks and impressions. BrandCommand helps multi-unit operators do exactly that, and this guide walks through how to measure advertising campaign performance step by step.
Campaign performance is the measured result of a marketing effort against the goal it was built to reach. Strong measurement connects spend, activity and revenue in one view. Weak measurement reports vanity numbers that look good in a slide deck but never reach the store level.
Here is the process we recommend, in order: define the outcome, pick the metrics, set up tracking, calculate the numbers, separate real impact from noise, and report it in a format leadership can act on.
Start With Business Outcomes and Campaign Objectives
Every measurement plan begins with a business outcome, not a metric. Ask what the campaign must change: more booked appointments, more phone calls, more online orders, or more qualified mortgage applications.
Write the outcome in one sentence. For example: “Increase booked estimates at each location by 15% in the quarter.” That sentence tells you what to measure and what counts as success.
Next, set the campaign objective. To compare marketing performance fairly across multiple franchise units, keep the same objective and definitions for every location. Objectives usually fall into three groups:
- Awareness: more people see and remember the brand in a local area
- Consideration: more people visit the location page, read reviews or request information
- Conversion: more people call, book, buy or apply
Each objective needs different metrics. A reach campaign judged on sales will always look like a failure. Match the measurement to the objective before any money is spent.
Choose the KPIs That Match Each Campaign Objective
A key performance indicator (KPI) is a number that shows progress toward an objective. Pick a small set, usually three to five, so the team can focus. The mistake most multi-location teams make is choosing one universal scorecard. The right KPIs depend on two things at once: the campaign objective and the channel carrying the ad. A metric that is diagnostic on search can be meaningless on display.
Start with the objective, then layer in the channel:
- Awareness: impressions, reach, frequency, branded search volume, estimated ad recall lift
- Consideration: click-through rate, engaged sessions, location page views, direction requests, review count and rating
- Conversion: conversion rate, cost per lead, cost per acquisition, revenue per location, return on ad spend
Now apply the channel lens. The same objective produces different primary metrics depending on where the ad runs:
- Search campaigns: impression share, click-through rate, cost per click, conversion rate, cost per acquisition. Search captures existing demand, so branded search volume is a weak success signal here, it is an input, not an output.
- Social campaigns: reach and frequency for awareness; thumb-stop rate, video completion rate and cost per engaged session for consideration; cost per lead and lead quality for conversion. Social also exposes audience quality through negative feedback and hide rates, which are early warnings that creative or targeting is off.
- Display campaigns: viewable impressions, view-through conversions (with caution), and cost per incremental visit. Display rarely closes the sale on the last click, so judging it on last-click CPA will always make it look like a failure.
- Video campaigns: completed views, cost per completed view, and brand lift where the platform supports a lift study. Completion rate is a creative diagnostic, not a business outcome.
Always track one leading indicator and one lagging indicator. Click-through rate shows early interest. Booked revenue shows whether that interest turned into business. When a leading indicator improves but the lagging indicator does not, the problem is usually downstream, landing page, offer, or lead follow-up, not the ad.
Set a target and a floor for each KPI before launch. A target is what good looks like; a floor is the level below which you pause or restructure the campaign. Without a floor, every review turns into an argument about whether the number is “good.”
Watch out: reporting a channel on a metric it was never built to move, display on last-click CPA, or awareness video on booked revenue, guarantees a false negative and can kill a campaign that is actually working.
Set Up Tracking Before the Campaign Launches
Tracking is the foundation of measurement. If it is missing at launch, the data you need is gone for good. Set it up before the first ad goes live, and treat it as a governed process across the network rather than a per-location task.
Check these items for every location:
- Unique tracking phone numbers or call tracking for each store
- UTM parameters on every link in every ad, using one naming standard
- Conversion events defined once and deployed consistently in the analytics platform
- Platform pixels and conversion APIs installed and verified on location pages
- Location pages with consistent naming and listing data
- A shared spreadsheet or dashboard that all locations use
- A documented consent approach that matches how the analytics and ad platforms are configured
Consistent tracking matters more across a franchise network than in a single shop. If one location names its UTM parameters differently, your totals will not add up. Set one naming standard and enforce it. A workable convention is lowercase, hyphenated, and ordered: source, medium, campaign, location ID. Document it in a shared sheet so new locations inherit the standard instead of inventing their own. With one naming standard in place, teams can track campaign links consistently across locations and compare performance without confusing local variations.
Reconcile Platform Numbers Against Analytics
Ad platforms and your analytics tool will almost never agree. Each counts conversions on its own attribution window, deduplicates differently, and may include view-through or modeled conversions. Expect a gap and decide in advance which source is the source of truth for each metric. A common pattern is to use the ad platform for spend and delivery, and analytics for on-site behavior and lead volume, then reconcile the two in one report rather than averaging them.
Account for Consent and Signal Loss
Privacy rules and browser restrictions mean some conversions will not be observable. Consent choices, cookie blocking, and cross-app tracking limits all reduce match rates. Build your reporting around that reality: rely on first-party conversion events on your own location pages, keep a server-side or API-based conversion path where the platform supports it, and treat modeled conversions as estimates rather than counts. Do not compare a pre-consent baseline to a post-consent period without noting the change.
Validate Before You Scale
Run a short validation pass before spending at full volume:
- Fire a test conversion on each location page and confirm it appears in both the analytics platform and the ad platform.
- Check that UTM values land in the expected report fields, not in a catch-all bucket.
- Confirm call tracking routes to the correct location and that recordings or logs are retained long enough to audit lead quality.
- Spot-check three locations against their platform dashboards to catch naming drift early.
Watch out: a campaign with no tracking is not a failed campaign, it is an unmeasured one, and you cannot tell the difference later. The same is true of a campaign with inconsistent tracking: the numbers look complete but cannot be trusted, which is worse than an obvious gap.
Calculate ROI, ROAS, Cost Per Lead and Cost Per Acquisition
Four formulas cover most campaign reporting. Use the same definitions across every location so comparisons are fair.
- Return on investment (ROI): (Revenue from campaign minus campaign cost) divided by campaign cost, then multiplied by 100
- Return on ad spend (ROAS): Revenue from campaign divided by ad spend
- Cost per lead (CPL): Total campaign cost divided by number of leads
- Cost per acquisition (CPA): Total campaign cost divided by number of customers won
These formulas are simple, but the inputs need care. Revenue should come from closed sales, not from form fills. Cost should include creative, media and agency fees, not just ad spend.
Worked Example: Calculating Campaign ROI
Suppose a franchise location spends $4,000 CAD on a local search and social campaign in one month. The campaign generates 120 leads and 30 booked jobs. Those jobs bring in $27,000 CAD in revenue.
- ROI: ($27,000 minus $4,000) divided by $4,000 = 5.75, or 575%
- ROAS: $27,000 divided by $4,000 = 6.75
- CPL: $4,000 divided by 120 = $33.33 CAD per lead
- CPA: $4,000 divided by 30 = $133.33 CAD per booked job
These numbers tell a clear story. The campaign returned almost seven dollars for every dollar spent, and each booked job cost about $133 CAD to win. Compare that figure to the average job value before deciding whether to scale.
The article’s worked example shows how the four core formulas produce concrete figures from one month of campaign data.
| Metric | Result | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| ROI | 575% | Return after subtracting the $4,000 cost |
| ROAS | 6.75 | Revenue returned per dollar of spend |
| CPL | $33.33 CAD | Cost per each of 120 leads |
| CPA | $133.33 CAD | Cost per each of 30 booked jobs |
Separate Attributed Results From Incremental Impact
Attribution tells you which marketing touchpoint gets credit for a conversion. Incrementality tells you whether the campaign caused the conversion at all. The two are not the same.
A customer who sees your ad, then searches your brand name and books, may have booked anyway. The ad gets credit in the platform, but it may not have changed the outcome.
To test incrementality, run a holdout. Keep a comparable group of locations or postal code areas out of the campaign for a set period. Then compare booking rates between the exposed group and the holdout. The gap shows the lift the campaign actually created.
Holdout tests take planning, but they are the only reliable way to know if spend is moving the needle. Many franchise operators skip them and end up funding campaigns that merely take credit for demand that already existed.
Keep in mind that attribution windows, delayed conversions and cross-device journeys can all distort results. A customer may research on a phone and book on a laptop a week later. Set your attribution window to match your typical sales cycle and document the choice.
Build a Campaign Performance Report Template
A good report answers three questions: what happened, why it happened, and what to do next. Keep it to one page per campaign, with the same layout for every location.

Use this template:
Campaign: [Name] | Locations included: [Count] | Period: [Dates]
Objective: [One sentence]
Spend: $[Amount] CAD
Results: Leads: [#] | Booked jobs: [#] | Revenue: $[Amount] CAD
Key metrics: ROI [%] | ROAS [x] | CPL $[ ] CAD | CPA $[ ] CAD
Incremental lift vs. holdout: [%]
Top-performing locations: [List]
Underperforming locations: [List and likely cause]
Next action: [One specific change]
Share the same template with every franchise location and review it on a set schedule, such as monthly. For a step-by-step approach to tracking local marketing results over time, follow the same layout across the network. Consistent reporting lets you spot patterns across the network, which is where the real gains usually are.
Book Your Local Visibility Score to Start Measuring Your Locations
Measurement only works when every location has accurate listings, consistent reviews and clean tracking. Fixing those basics first makes every later number more reliable. BrandCommand gives multi-unit operators one governed system for local search, map and review visibility, plus a clear view of what is driving results at each store.
If you want to see where your locations stand today, start with a free Local Visibility Score. It shows how each location appears in search and maps, so you can measure from a sound starting point.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you measure the performance of an advertising campaign?
Measure campaign performance by comparing results against the objective you set before launch. Start by defining the business outcome, such as leads, bookings or sales. Then track the matching KPIs, including cost per lead, conversion rate and return on ad spend, over a measurement window long enough to capture delayed conversions. Compare these figures against your historical benchmarks and a control period where possible. Use a consistent reporting cadence so you can spot trends and decide whether to adjust spend or creative.
How do you calculate advertising campaign ROI?
Advertising ROI is calculated as (revenue attributable to the campaign minus campaign cost) divided by campaign cost, then multiplied by 100 to express it as a percentage. For example, if a campaign costs CAD 5,000 and generates CAD 15,000 in attributable revenue, the ROI is (15,000 minus 5,000) divided by 5,000, or 200 percent. Attributable revenue depends on your attribution model, so state which model you use and apply it consistently across campaigns to keep comparisons fair.
What is the difference between ROAS and ROI?
Return on ad spend (ROAS) measures revenue generated for each dollar spent on advertising, calculated as attributed revenue divided by ad spend. Return on investment (ROI) accounts for all costs, not just media spend, and shows net profitability. ROAS is useful for quick channel comparisons, while ROI shows whether a campaign actually made money after overheads such as creative production and agency fees. Use ROAS for day-to-day optimization and ROI for budget decisions.
How can you track which ads generate leads or sales?
Use unique tracking parameters on every ad link, such as UTM tags, along with conversion tracking pixels on your forms and checkout pages. Assign a distinct phone number or landing page to each campaign where possible, and pass lead source data into your CRM so each sale can be traced back to its originating ad. Check that tracking fires correctly on each device and location before spending the full budget.
